In Pursuit of Balance—The Tasting

Last week, I went up to New York for the In Pursuit of Balance tasting. The trip up was a little eventful, but we got to the tasting shortly after 1:00. I went there with Joe Roberts (aka 1winedude), which certainly has some advantages—he not only got me into the tasting, but he also introduced me to plenty of people. There are also a few drawbacks. First, as you might expect, everyone knows him, and they all want to chat him up. I did not ask him about it, but I would think it would get a bit tiring after a while….

There was the woman that he ran into at the restaurant. I told him to invite her over to join us at least in part to dismiss what must have been the impression of everyone in the place (think about it—two relatively clean-cut guys, eating lunch together in a Tribeca restaurant on a Tuesday, drinking a bottle of Prosecco, a bottle of rosé Prosecco–not that there is anything wrong with that). Then there was the guy at the check-in who grabbed his ear for about ten minutes while I was looking to get my drink on.

That brings us to the second disadvantage. I am a pretty hard guy to ignore—I am 6’4” and weigh, well let’s just say ”around” 200 pounds. During the tasting, though (starting with the guy at the reception), it seemed that people were actively ignoring me as if I were holding out my glass asking for money at an intersection. Once they saw the Dude, I instantly became invisible.

Yes, I am a bit of a sensitive type.

We eventually got up to the tasting and I realized that I did not have a pen. What a dope. I always try to take some tasting notes at events like this, and I was determined to do an even better job this time, but that would be a problem without a pen. I looked around a bit to try and steal one, but gave up and took the notes on my phone. As many of you know, I use a numerical scale, something that Joe has railed against for some time now. He mentioned again that I should ditch it, but I am bigger than him (as in a 6’4” to less than that sense—not a thedrunkencyclist.com vs. 1winedude.com sense, of course).

Right off the elevator was Ross Cobb. I met him once before, when I was out at Hirsch, and he has become a bit of a rock star in the Sonoma Coast Pinot world. He makes the wines for Hirsch, and has previously worked at Flowers and Williams Selyem among others. He also has his own label, the three he was pouring were $70 and all tiny productions:

’08 Coastlands: Rich and fruity but refined. Can do a lot worse. 90-92

’09 Joy Road: Tight but good fruit a little more on the back end. 90-92
’08 Jack Hill: Softer fruit, deeper, great acidity. 91-93
 
We next headed over to Ant Hill Farms.
Joe Roberts

Joe Roberts

 
’11 Comptchee Ridge ($46): Vibrant acidity but where is the depth and finish? 87-89
’12 Campbell Ranch: Better balance and finish than the Comptche but lacks some backbone. 88-90.
’12 Sonoma Coast ($34): Fun wine with a killer finish. Best (and cheapest) of the three. 90-92.
 
We then made a b-line over to Matthiasson, a winery that Joe knows very well. Steve Matthiasson, the owner/vintner was pouring and seemed like a really nice guy—he actually noticed that I was standing there.
 
’12 Linda Vista Chardonnay ($25): Great green apple. No malo. Neutral oak. Great wine for the price. 89-91.
’12 Sonoma Coast Chardonnay ($45): Wow. Great body and depth. Fantastic. 91-93.
 
Next was Hirsch where Jasmine was pouring. Joe wanted to see if she would do a quick interview for 1winedude and I wanted to give her some grief for not initially accepting me for the trade tasting. It would probably end up costing me some good karma, but that was a risk I was willing to take.
Jasmine HIrsch

Jasmine Hirsch

 
’12 Estate Chard ($65): Great lemon and a bit of spice. Incredible depth and finish. Needs time but this is gonna be killer (California term). 92-94.
’11 San Andreas Pinot ($63): A typical young San Andreas. Great acidity that masks the fruit a bit. Needs time. 89-91.
’11 Reserve Pinot ($90): Wow. Big fruit and trying to work it all out. But the acidity is there just needs time. Maybe a lot of time. 91-93.
 
Halfway through the Hirsch stop, I saw one of my all time favorite wine personalities: Andrea Immer Robinson (we were drinking from her “The One” glass at the tasting). Don’t tell my wife, but I fell in love with her watching her “Simply Wine” TV show.
 
I had to meet her.
 
We next hit Failla since I saw that Ehren Jordan was there pouring. Ehren is another rock star in the wine making business and despite having been to Failla countless times, I had never met him (but have never fallen in love with him).
Ehren Jordan of Failla

Ehren Jordan of Failla

 
’12 Sonoma Coast Chardonnay ($35): Big and oaky. Good acidity but a bit flabby. 87-89.
’12 Haynes Vineyard Chard ($55): Richer nose. Much more focused. And vibrant. Wow. Needs time. 92-94.
’12 Sonoma Coast Pinot ($35): Solid. Great fruit and balance. 90-92.
’12 Keefer Ranch Pinot ($60?): Wow. I usually lean toward Failla’s Chards but this Pinot rocks. 92-94.
’12 Savoy Pinot ($60?): A bit fruity for me but great verve 90-92.
 
After Failla, I went looking for Andrea—I had embarrassed myself (and my wife) before by introducing myself to a total stranger, so I had no fear.
 
Problem: could not find her.
 
Instead, I found Joe at the Sandhi/Domaine de la Côte table—both wines from Rajat Parr.
 
Sandhi
’12 Sta Rita Hills Pinot ($35): Pretty solid effort. Vibrant, very good. 90-92.
’12 “Wenzlau” Pinot ($45): Tight but some blueberry. Lacking a bit acidity initially but eventually comes through. 90-92.
’12 “Rinconada” Pinot ($55): Close to the real deal. Fruit, acidity. Bam. 91-93.
 
Domaine de la Côte20140211-084654.jpg
’11 Domaine de la Cote Sta Rita Hills ($45): A bit of Brett but still great fruit. Reminded me of a Haut Côte de Nuits. 86-88.
’11 “Bloom’s Field” Pinot ($55): No Brett this time and great fruit. A bit short on the finish. 88-90.
’11 La Côte Pinot ($90): The nose is dominated by clove and his thing rocks. Most depth and intensity so far. Incredible. 93-95.
 
Another wine maker that was supposed to be there was Adam Tolmach of The Ojai vineyard. He was not there, but I wanted to try his wines nonetheless.
 
photo 3’11 Solomon Hills Chardonnay ($33): I was really impressed with this particularly given its entry-level status. 89-91.
’11 Puerta del Mar Chadonnay ($33): Richer peachier profile. Initially round and fat but followed by biting acidity. 91-93.
’11 “Kick on Ranch” Pinot ($55): Lower alcohol. Great fruit. My style but still young. 89-91.
Special bottling Syrah ($??): Planted in the middle of Chard and Pinot. Fantastic nose and depth. Would love to taste in 10 years. 91-93.
 
Next up Peay Vineyards and Twomey. Still no Andrea, but I did meet Mary Ewing-Mulligan and Ed McCarthy, the authors of Wine for Dummies.
Ed McCarthy

Ed McCarthy

Peay Vineyards
’12 Sonoma Coast Pinot ($??): Really nice. Needs time but will blossom. 87-89.
’12 Savoy Pinot ($??): Wow. Awesome fruit finesse verve. 92-94.
 
Twomey
’11 Anderson Valley Pinot ($50): Fruity and round but not enough verve. 85-87.
’11 Russian River Pinot ($50): More focused and bright. 88-90.
 
At the end of the tasting, I filmed a brief interview for Joe with Jasmine and then we headed out. We made our way back up to Penn Station and had an early dinner at a deli  before catching our train back to Philly. I would love to tell you that Andrea Immer (I’ve decided to never use her married name) walked in to the deli and sat down with us, but we both know that did not happen.
 
Oh well, maybe some day….
 
I knew that bad karma with Jasmine would come back and bite me.
Unknown's avatar

About the drunken cyclist

I have been an occasional cycling tour guide in Europe for the past 20 years, visiting most of the wine regions of France. Through this "job" I developed a love for wine and the stories that often accompany the pulling of a cork. I live in Houston with my lovely wife and two wonderful sons.
This entry was posted in Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Wine, Wine Tasting. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to In Pursuit of Balance—The Tasting

  1. Shelley's avatar Shelley says:

    How fun was that? I would have to buy one bottle a week to afford some of those fabulous wines. Maybe I will look through your site for a list of “Wines for the newly retired.” 🙂

    Like

  2. Linda Foxworth, CSW, CSS, WSET 3, FWS's avatar foxress says:

    Wow, quite a lot of rock stars there. I would have been desperately seeking Andrea, too. I think she’s a bit of a wine genius.

    Like

  3. PinotNinja's avatar PinotNinja says:

    And with that you’ve added a whole new stack of wines onto my “must hunt for these desperately” list!

    Like

  4. Stefano's avatar Stefano says:

    What a cool event and experience! And of course, great reporting as always.

    Like

Leave a reply to PinotNinja Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.