Well, That Ain’t Kosher…

I get invited to my fair share of events these days. I guess part of it is due to the fact that this blog has been around for a while and some figure that it merits attention. Or, more than likely, I live only two hours from New York City and inviting me is a relatively low-cost venture.

Virtually every week, as far as I can tell, there is some sort of tasting in the city, and during the Spring and Fall, there are usually multiple tastings every day.

In the past, I turned down far more of these events than I attended since even though Philly is relatively close to New York, it is still takes a bit of determination and time to get up there (and I do have a day job, after all).

My approach has been slightly different these past six months or so as my family and I will be moving to Texas this July.

And Texas is not two hours away from New York City.

Usually, tastings are held between 12-5 during the week so I head up the I-95 corridor for the day, coming back on a late train or, increasingly, bus. It is not that bad a trip as I am able to get a bit a work done during the journey.

A few weeks ago, however, I was invited to an Oscars Party hosted by Piper-Heidsieck. If you start doing a little of the math: there would be a lot of champagne to drink, the Academy Awards start in the evening and usually don’t end until midnight, and there would be a lot of champagne to drink.

I got a hotel.

The following day (Monday), I was also invited to the Kosher Wine and Food Experience (KWFE) at Pier 60 along the Hudson River. At first, I had no intention of going as my view of Kosher wines was not at all favorable.

Chelsea Piers

Chelsea Piers

And that is being kind.

While in College, I was really good friends with our basketball team’s manager. He was Jewish and lived just outside of Washington D.C. I would often go down to his house for the High Holidays, particularly after I started teaching in Baltimore. I spent so much time with his family that I learned quite a bit of Yiddish, developed a strong affinity for traditionally Jewish food, and I eventually earned HMOT status (Honorary Member of the Tribe).

Well, that is not entirely true; I did not have an affinity for all Jewish fare. Gefilte fish is rather nasty and Kosher wine was pretty awful. My adopted father of sorts, insisted that there was always a bottle of Manischewitz on the table.

Talk about nasty.

Manischewitz was not represented, but there were some that were almost as bad (OK, not quite...).

Manischewitz was not represented, but there were some that were almost as bad (OK, not quite…).

(If you have never tried Manischewitz, don’t. It is made from concord grapes and is further sweetened by adding high fructose corn syrup. Yeah.)

This all occurred during my nascent wine fascination and I have since always linked “Kosher Wine?” with “No, I’ll just have a Miller Lite.”

That was until I attended the KWFE. The event featured hundreds of different wines, with nearly every major wine making region represented, including at least a half-dozen champagnes.

Which is where I started. Naturally.

I eventually made my way around the room, hitting most of the French producers, many of the American makers, stopped in Spain, and a couple from Israel.

My takeaways?

That's Laurent-Perrier behind the hordes of tasters.

That’s Laurent-Perrier behind the hordes of tasters.

First: not all Kosher wine is horrible (although there is still some pretty bad stuff out there), in fact, in many cases it is virtually indistinguishable from the non-Kosher equivalents.

Second: the food served at the event was fantastic. About a third of the room was dedicated to food and there was everything from chili to beef to ice cream being dished out.

Third: making Kosher wine is quite the undertaking for a mainstream winery. As soon as the fruit comes in, only Sabbath-observing Jews are allowed anywhere near the process. In fact, the winery has to have a dedicated room and equipment for its production and winery personnel are not even allowed in the same room as the fruit/wine until after bottling. This means that the winemaker and all those involved in the production of the wine have to be brought in to perform even the most mundane tasks.

The food was crazy, crazy good. Reason enough to go.

The food was crazy, crazy good. Reason enough to go.

I spent a bit of time talking with Menachem Israelievitch, the chief winemaker for Royal Wine, who lives in Paris. He makes all the European wine in the Royal portfolio, which includes a white Sancerre, a Provençal rosé, a red from the Loire, six champagnes, and a rosé and seven reds from eight estates in Bordeaux. And that’s just France!


That is a large reason that Kosher wines tend to run $10-15 more than their non-Kosher equivalents: every time anything needs to be done in the winery, they have to bring the labor in, usually from Paris (there are not a lot of sabbath observing Jews living in Bordeaux, Champagne, or Provence apparently).

Imagine poor Menachem’s harvest for a moment (well, clearly, he is not poor in the financial sense) over the course of maybe six weeks, he oversees production at close to two dozen wineries in ten different regions in four countries.

Oy vey.

Slightly better than Manischewitz.

Slightly better than Manischewitz.

Third, only those approved by the rabbi could serve the wine at the tasting. The winery representatives in attendance were allowed to move unopened bottles but once it was time to pull the cork, it was hands off. The official pourers would take your glass, rinse it out with water, turn their back to you, pour the wine in the glass, and then hand the glass back to you. For every pour. Many (most?) of the pourers were clearly not “wine people” which normally would not be a big deal (since there was a winery representative to talk about the wine), but clearly those opening the bottles of champagne needed a bit more practice–I saw them douse the crowd several times.

Oy vey iz mir.

Honestly? If I am anywhere near New York next year for the Kosher Wine and Food Experience, I will do all that I can to attend. The food is great, many of the wines are outstanding, and there is no Manischewitz in sight.

And I am pretty sure it will serve to renew my HMOT status.



About the drunken cyclist

I have been an occasional cycling tour guide in Europe for the past 20 years, visiting most of the wine regions of France. Through this "job" I developed a love for wine and the stories that often accompany the pulling of a cork. I live in Houston with my lovely wife and two wonderful sons.
This entry was posted in Kosher Wine, Wine. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to Well, That Ain’t Kosher…

  1. Chuck says:

    Jeff that was very interesting, honestly I had never even thought about wine being kosher or not.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I haven’t gotten the chance to try it, but I hear that Hagafen Cellars makes some amazing Kosher wine. Also, I haven’t had it for years, but when I was a kid I remember really liking gefilte fish! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Nice – I’m interviewing my first Kosher winemaker now…geek on!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Peggy Bright says:

    But for this post my opinion of Kosher wines would have been permanently stuck on Manischewitz. Thanks

    Liked by 1 person

  5. lulu says:

    Your blog has opened some interesting, fun doors for you. BTW, it’s a beautiful day in Houston.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. chef mimi says:

    Very interesting! By the way, I thought all Sancerre was white…

    Liked by 1 person

  7. any plans to do any west coast events? Eroica and seaotter are just around the corner…

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.